Ideas Have Consequences

Plato said ideas rule the world. All action begins with an idea. Paul said, “Take every thought captive to Christ (2 Cor 10:5). “Ideas have consequences and some ideas can lead to brutal outcomes. For example, the most prominent indicator of whether a female will be sold to a brothel, killed as a fetus, abused in her marriage or family, or denied a place of decision making in her community or marriage is determined not by her gender, but by the value we place on females as a whole. Research concludes that when culture values females as much as males, equal numbers of girls and boys survive to adulthood. Gender-justice begins with an idea—valuing females and males equally.

What is more, when communities extend females equal authority in decision making and resources to develop their abilities, this lowers female-abuse. It also raises the economic stability within their communities. NGOS’ call this the girl effect. Christians might call this the ezer effect, because in the early chapters of Genesis the Bible suggests that females are created to provide vital help—a fact noted in Genesis 2:18. According to the scholar R. David Freedman, the Hebrew word used to describe woman’s help (ezer) arises from two Hebrew roots that mean “to rescue, to save,” and “to be strong.” Ezer is found twenty-one times in the Old Testament. Of these references, fourteen are used for God, and four refer to military rescue. Perhaps the most familiar of these uses is Psalm 121:1-2 where ezer is used for God’s rescue of Israel: “I lift up my eyes to the mountains—where does my help come from? My help comes from the Lord, the Maker of heaven and earth.” God created woman to provide not inferior but strong rescue.

Throughout Scripture women are never depicted as inferior but as equal to males in every significant way. Males and females are:

  • Equally created in God’s image.
  • Equally called to share authority in caring for the earth and in being fruitful.
  • Equally responsible for and equally distorted by sin.
  • Equally redeemed by Christ and equally gifted by the Holy Spirit.
  • Equally held accountable for using their gifts in service to others.

Despite numerous examples of female rescue and leadership throughout Scripture and church history, church leaders have continually offered a patriarchal evaluation of the female gender as a whole. Consider the following examples:

  • Irenaeus (130–202 A.D.)  “Both nature and the law place the woman in a subordinate condition to the man”
  • Augustine (354–430) “Nor can it be doubted, that it is more consonant with the order of nature that men should bear rule over women, than women over men.”
  • Chrysostom (347–407) “The woman taught once, and ruined all. On this account …let her not teach… for the sex is weak and fickle…”
  • John Calvin (1509-1564) In his commentary on Timothy said that women are “not to assume authority over the man… it is not permitted by their condition.”
  • John Knox (1514-1572) “Nature, I say, does paint [women] forth to be weak, frail, impatient, feeble, and foolish; and experience has declared them to be inconstant, variable, cruel…  Since flesh is subordinate to spirit, a woman’s place is beneath man’s.”
  • Mark Driscoll (a popular pastor of Mars Hill, a mega church in Seattle) wrote:

…when it comes to leading in the church, women are unfit because they are more gullible and easier to deceive than men. … women who fail to trust [Paul’s] instruction … are much like their mother Eve. . . Before you get all emotional like a woman in hearing this, please consider the content of the women’s magazines at your local grocery store that encourages liberated women in our day to watch porno with their boyfriends, master oral sex for men who have no intention of marrying them…– and ask yourself if it doesn’t look like the Serpent is still trolling the garden and that the daughters of Eve aren’t gullible in pronouncing progress, liberation, and equality.

Do ideas like these, that devalue females at the level of being, have consequences? According to two prominent Christian missionaries, Katharine Bushnell (1856-1946) and Josephine Butler (1828-1906), the proliferation of the sexual slave industry will never end until Christians oppose patriarchy in their ranks. After infiltrating brothels established by the British army in India, Bushnell discovered first-hand the abuses females suffered when abused by British soldiers. After years of working to free abused women around the world, Butler and Bushnell began to see that the global abuse of women was inseparable from a devaluation of females posited by Christian faith. Bushnell argued that the abuse of women will not be overcome as long as “the subordination of woman to man was taught within the body of Christians.” Butler and Bushnell agreed that:

Just so long as men imagine that a system of caste is taught in the Word of God, and that they belong to the upper caste while women are of the lower caste; and just so long as they believe that mere flesh—fate—determines the caste to which one belongs; and just so long as they believe that…Genesis 3:16 [teaches] “thy desire shall be for thy husband, and he shall rule over you”…the destruction of young women into a prostitute class [will] continue.

But place Christian women where God intends them to stand, on a plane of full equality with men in the church and home, where their faculties, their will, their consciences are controlled only by the God who made man and woman equal by creation…then the world will become a much purer [place] than it is today. . .(Katharine Bushnell, Dr. Katharine Bushnell: A Brief Sketch of her Life Work, (Hertford, England: Rose and Sons, Salisbury Square, date of publication unknown), pp. 13-14.)

Bushnell’s work among abused women gave her an opportunity to notice the link between abuse and the presumed inferiority of women, promoted by all religious and philosophical traditions, including Christianity. Like Katharine Bushnell and other egalitarians from the past several centuries, Christians today show how Scripture opposes patriarchy and the flawed view that women are inferior to, and in need of, male authority.

Christians for Biblical Equality (CBE) exists to challenge patriarchy within the ranks of our own Christian churches. We believe that the Church cannot advance the justice integral to Christ’s kingdom without challenging patriarchy in churches, organizations, and relationships. For this reason, CBE will convene a conference July 29-31 in Seattle, Washington, focused on “Building Biblical Community: Transforming Sex, Power, and Prejudice.” The conference will answer questions like: Why would God give gifts to women, only to exclude women from using them? Are male-only models of authority biblical? Does male authority lead to abuse?

Featuring four general sessions, panels, and twenty workshops, this three day conference will include Christians serving all over the world. Richard Howell, the General Secretary of the Asia Evangelical Alliance and the Evangelical Fellowship of India, will examine abuse, gender hierarchy, and a biblical response to dominance. MaryKate Morse, Quaker minister, professor, and author of Making Room for Leadership: Power, Space, and Influence, will consider biblical models of leadership that harmonize servant leadership and power. Linguist, scholar, and author of Man and Woman: One in Christ Philip B. Payne will explore the textual evidence for the shared authority between men and women in church and home. Kanyere Eaton, pastor at Fellowship Covenant Church in the Bronx, NY, will address the difficulties African-American women face in their paths to ordination. Conference sessions will also examine pornography, abuse, biblical marriage, women in ministry, singleness, leadership, and grassroots activism.

Scholars, ministry leaders, and laypeople representing many denominations will join us in July from countries throughout Asia, Europe, and the Arab world. Students are participating in large numbers due to CBE’s student paper competition, which gives three students a forum to present original research on the conference theme. CBE is also offering need-based conference scholarships, and students and others are welcome to apply for financial assistance. Conference registration will be open until July 29th and all are invited to join CBE in Seattle!

CBE is the largest evangelical organization providing biblical resources on the shared authority and service of men and women. CBE sponsors annual conferences, hosts local chapters, runs an online book service, and publishes two award-winning journals and a weekly e-newsletter. CBE’s journals have received more than twenty Evangelical Press Association awards.

For more information, contact us. To register for “Building Biblical Community: Transforming Sex, Power, and Prejudice,” visit the conference webpage.

Christians for Biblical Equality
122 W Franklin Ave, Suite 218
Minneapolis, MN 55404-2451
Phone: (612) 872-6898
Fax: (612) 872-6891
Email: cbe@cbeinternational.org
Web: cbeinternational.org

—-
Mimi Haddad is the President of Christians for Biblical Equality


Print Friendly

About the Author

Mimi HaddadMimi Haddad is the president of Christians for Biblical Equality.View all posts by Mimi Haddad →

  • Pingback: The World Wide (Religious) Web for Thursday, June 16, 2011 « GeorgePWood.com

  • Noel Pendley

    That Driscoll quote makes me angry!!   Who are the boyfriends watching porno, who are the men waiting to be serviced?   Who is sending the message?

    Makes me think of a teenager I worked with years ago – they had her on the highest adult does of Prozac available and every time she went back to the doc he told her how messed up she was.   I am sure that I would continue to have major problems regardless of the meds I was put on, if I was continually told I was messed up.  Wait, that’s part of my story too; and I’m a man – guess we’re all subject to the serpent in the garden.

    • LightByGrace

      Amen…I think Driscoll forgets about all the men who are deceived, give into temptation and harm other people (Did he never read the story of David??)…Falling short of the glory of God isn’t a matter of gender. It’s a human thing.

      • Brian

        I think that maybe if we read all these quotes in their fullest context, they might make a bit more sense.
        It’s not a case of men being holier than women or women being more sinful than men. I have no doubt my wife understands holiness much better than I.

        • Lightbygrace

          What it is a case of, do you think? 

        • Lightbygrace

          I don’t think that Driscoll is saying men are holier than women…I think he is saying that he believes women are more easily deceived than men and that we are spiritually weaker (and therefore are more commonly victims of demonic influence). In fact that is what he says…I get this not just from the quote in this article but from a podcast of his that I listened to. You can find it here: http://www.marshillchurch.org/media/spiritual-warfare/introduction-to-spiritual-warfare.
          (ramble alert!  :) )…
          The other issue that arises from this ‘weaker vessel’/patriarchal attitude is something that was taught by a pastor who I dearly love and agree with on many other things. There’s an idea that men are responsible for the spiritual matters of women. He suggested that if God were to knock on his door to discuss a spiritual matter in his household and his wife answered the door that God would say to her “Hi Joann, where’s Tim?”. As if Joann is not fit to be responsible for her family’s spiritual well-being, so Tim, the man, must be talked to  first. Well, if that is how a couple decides to manage their household, great…What about couples who do not believe this is the way it should be? What about single women? What about women who are married to a man who doesn’t care about spiritual matters? Does she then fall under the ‘cover’ of her father? What if he is dead? At what point is a woman trusted to be a spiritual leader? Only as a reluctant substitute in the absence of a man? I believe that Jesus set all of us free to be in direct relationship with God. I respect my man as a spiritual equal. Together we manage the spiritual matters of our life as a couple. I don’t need him to be responsible for my relationship with God or my mistakes, and he doesn’t need me to do that for him. Sure, we may need each other’s prayer support and encouragement, but not because one of us is inherently, by design of our gender,  ’weaker’ or more vulnerable to deception. I believe that together as one, side by side,women and men create a much stronger force against evil than if they walk with one following in the spiritual shadow of the other. 

  • LightbyGrace

    Good article…Mark Driscoll made my sh** list when I was listening to a teaching he did about spiritual warfare. He stated that in his experience as a pastor he found that women were more easily deceived by the devil than men…He said this makes sense because the Bible says it’s true. He talked about Eve (as he did in the above quote), and about the Bible saying that women are the weaker vessel. He gave the tired ol’ ‘it doesn’t come from me, it comes from the Bible’ line. Needless to say, I stopped listening to the podcast and my hackles go up when I hear his name. Usually I can disagree with someone and still respect them as a teacher, but I won’t tolerate that kind of ignorance because, as this blog post points out, that kind of view of any entire group of people leads to some ugly stuff. I love him as a brother but at the same time I’d like to kick him in the shins!

  • Dr Truth
  • http://profiles.google.com/laurankerr Lauran Kerr-Heraly

    Ms. Haddad you are awesome! I’m a CBE member so I follow your writing and I am glad to see it here. :)

  • http://thehyphenhouse.blogspot.com LKH

    Awesome! I’m a CBE member so I follow Haddad’s writing. Glad to see it here!

  • Anonymous

    Deeply grateful for the reminder that “ezer” comes from the roots for “strong” and “rescuer.”  Now that I’m in my 50s, I realize how much of my life has been spent being a “strong rescuer” for the men in my life (as they have often helped me).  Mark Driscoll is leading many astray, and no doubt he will one day regret it.  As his young congregation grows up, many of them will begin to see that in real life, it doesn’t work that way.  Unfortunately, some won’t allow themselves to see it.

    • Lightbygrace

      Good point – we rescue each other. Each of us as human beings will need rescue from time to time. Some of us will be deceived, some will be spiritually weak, but not because our gender dictates it. If we stop judging people’s capabilities based on sex we might be able to discern one another’s strengths without limitation…And better serve the goal to bring Heaven to earth. 

  • Pingback: Round up – 8/7/11 « Sarah Starrenburg

×

TRENDING: Five Reasons Christian Parents "Lose" Their Children