RLC Exclusive Film Premier on Creative Civil Disobedience

The Bonhoeffer 4

Protest has evolved since my days as a professor at the University of Penn. Please do not misunderstand, I’m in no way saying there isn’t still a place for sit-ins at the White House and picket signs, as I did during Vietnam. But when the Iraq war broke out in 2003 and Shane Claiborne and friends traveled to the middle of the war zone with the Christian Peacemaker Teams I realized there had been a shift. I took my students, armed with picket signs, to the White House. Shane and a few friends packed their bags and headed for the war itself.

At the same time on the other side of the world my friend Jarrod McKenna (featured in Julian Masters short film “The Bonhoeffer 4”) engaged in his first nonviolent civil disobedience as a youth pastor at the age of twenty-one. It’s important to note how acts of civil disobedience are changing. Jarrod is at the forefront of what he calls “creative acts of civil disobedience”:

  • Planting vine and fig trees… on military bases(!)
  • Holding a worship service in front of hundreds of riot police
  • Dressing as ‘Captain Planet’s Planeteers’ while shutting down the world’s largest coal port
  • Training activists in nonviolence in oppressive situations in the Middle East and Eastern Europe
  • Picking olives in Palestine
  • Involvement  in outreach and peace-building with groups listed as terrorist organizations in Indonesia
  • Planting “guerrilla gardens”
  • Facilitating three hundred environmentalists at an protest with a “clown army”

Yet, the demonstration in this film is one of the most pronounced and prophetic forms of civil disobedience I’ve ever seen.

This film is about one of his most provocative actions that was discussed in the Australian Senate; while 20,000 U.S. and Australian troops trained for war in live fire exercises (guns were being fired and bombs dropped!) Jessica Morrison, Simon Moyle, Margaret Pestorius and Jarrod interrupted them by placing themselves in the middle of it!

Also by Tony: Steve Chalke Drops the Bomb in Support of Committed, Faithful, Same-Sex Relationships

Phyllis Tickle has said of this film: “The Bonhoeffer 4 is the effective and affecting visual record of how a few ordinary, vulnerable, but persuaded, Australians assumed together the dangers of standing up in a radical way against militarism in their own part of the first-world. To follow what the 4 do as they do it and to listen to their hearts as they explain their reasons for doing it, is to touch again the heritage both of Dietrich Bonhoeffer and of the Nazarene from Whom he himself received it.”

And we are now pleased for the first time in its entirety to premier “The Bonhoeffer 4: Living a Costly Grace in the Face of War”:

The Bonhoeffer 4 – Living a costly grace in the face of war from julian masters on Vimeo.

As I watched the film I wrote a few things down:

“We are seeking to be faithful to the call of Jesus to be peacemakers in our whole lives”

“Christianity should give more offense”.

“It’s all very nice to go to protest marches and write letters but in the face of a literal massacre by our government with our money, is that all we are going to do?”

“Christianity stands or falls with its revolutionary protest against violence.”

“This Christianity that we are soaked in, that seems so normal, that seems so safe, that’s so respectable, is in fact playing chaplain to the satanic system that is costing us the earth at the cost of the poor around the world.”

“All the good that you do will not come from you but from the fact that you have allowed yourself in the obedience of faith to be used by God’s love”.

“You just need to realize that war makes money, and money is what makes the world go round. The sooner you realize that, the sooner you will fit in with the rest of us.”

“Christianity without discipleship is always Christianity without Christ.”

What lines stuck with you? What do you think of these provocative actions? Regardless of if we agree, it’s unquestionably important to discuss. I’m consistently amazed by the creative imagination of the young people in Christendom today!


Tony Campolo is the Founder and President of EAPE and Professor Emeritus of Sociology at Eastern University. Most recently he co-authored Red Letter Revolution: What If Jesus Really Meant What He Said with Shane Claiborne. Look for Tony in your area and follow him on Facebook and Twitter.

Print Friendly

About the Author

Tony Campolo

Tony CampoloTony Campolo is the Founder and President of EAPE and Professor Emeritus of Sociology at Eastern University. Look for Tony in your area and follow him on Facebook and Twitter.View all posts by Tony Campolo →

  • bluecenterlight

    “Christianity should give more offense”. Christianity has taken a form in America that is proud to be offensive to sinners. Yet, biblical Christianity was welcoming to sinners and offensive to the religious establishment. 2000 years and we still bicker over grace vs. the law. Lord God send a revival of your grace, let it wash over our land and empower us to kick the living s%&# out of our enemy, in Jesus name.

  • Simon Moyle

    Just need to clarify: as one member of the “Bonhoeffer Four”, we were never in any danger. There are zones in Shoalwater Bay clearly marked for bombing, and we wouldn’t go in there (no one does – too much unexploded ordinance). The bombing was never anywhere near us (though we heard it in the distance). And they don’t use live bullets in exercises, they’d kill themselves firing at each other! The biggest danger realistically is vehicles coming through the bush at night and accidentally running over us, and that was unlikely too because it’s such a massive area. (Then there’s the snakes, spiders, paralysis ticks etc of the Australian bush…hehe;)). So while we were there to get in the way, and it sounds spectacular to say “guns were being fired and bombs dropped”, the reality is it was much less dangerous than it sounds.

    Even the legal consequences (at least for us in Australia) are pretty minimal – other than the night in the holding cell, we were never going to see the inside of a prison cell for this kind of action.

    And all of that’s good news, because it means that anyone can do this kind of action! Nonviolent resistance and even civil disobedience are not for the hardcore or heroes, but for ordinary folks like you (and me!) who want to be faithful to the love we’ve been shown in Jesus. So get creative, find a bunch of people who can support you and join you, and experiment with it. You’ll love it.

    • http://twitter.com/KingdomMatt Matt Young

      Brother Simon, any good resources you would recommend , books/sermons etc on the topic of civil disobedience?

  • Margaret Pestorius

    Though it seems, according to police reports the following year, that we did indeed paralyse the personnel and equipment and, as Rev. Bonhoeffer suggests, jammed a spoke into the wheel of oppression. Military training is just an extension of military action:

    • http://twitter.com/KingdomMatt Matt Young

      From a current U.S. Soldier, turned pacifist….that is so true!

  • http://www.facebook.com/simone.stuart Simone Stuart

    Christianty without discipleship is christianity without christ… So true. People need people. We were created for relationship and to ignore this purpose is to ignore people. To ignore people is to forget christ. I find this to be a wonderfully uncomfortable challenge! Lord never let me get comfy! ;-)

  • http://www.facebook.com/prchrturtle Mary Ridings Guarino

    hey i have a crappy computer so i can’t watch it on here but i would love to use our bluray which has a vimeo app. however, when searching on the app, this doesn’t show up… any ideas?

    • http://www.facebook.com/prchrturtle Mary Ridings Guarino

      it finally came up – our internet was acting up. had to type in the whole name of the film a few times for it to come up on search

  • http://www.facebook.com/alexander.holmesbrown Alexander Jordan Holmes-Brown

    In a small but important way, the Bonhoeffer 4′s act of civil disobedience and arrest as an action against the war, is an example for us who wish to understand how the mission and ministry of Jesus matters today. In a world facing the same problems of structural racism, war profiteering and manufactured poverty that Jeremiah and Jesus and Shakespeare and Orwell and King told us about, creative non-violent challenge to the state is as important as it was in the time of our great prophets. To often we live in such polite company that even talking about these things is to be radical. The problems of ecological catastrophe and the reality of the nuclear age are two of the most obvious reasons that our communities must really internalise the message of non-violent activism handed down by our heroes of the faith.

    In the meantime, our schools will continue to teach an alternate reality where poverty is accidental, where wars are natural and where economics is about numbers rather than human communities and the distribution of power and access to Life. Imagine if our schools taught us how to conquer injustice through love? Well, it’d need a conversation on what the injustices are and we’re not always ready for where that conversation will lead and what it’ll bring up. We avoid it at the cost of ourselves, our children, and the integrity they see in us. Let’s not look back and ask why more people weren’t like Bonhoeffer in the face of obvious evil. Let’s be encouraged to act critically and think critically about what Bonhoeffer might see today if he were here, and what the memory of the saints is calling us to.

  • SheriffBart

    I can think of more ways of civil disobedience:
    1. Speaking out on violence in the Middle East, such as Hamas lobbing rockets into Israel and killing innocent civilians.
    2. Marching on Washington for the unborn.
    3. Speaking out on the repressive regime in Iran, which has butchered thousands of political opponents.
    4. Speaking out on forcing Catholic hospitals to dispense medicine that is contrary to their religious beliefs.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000699994198 David Reynolds

    Fantastic stuff. Compelling, and frankly confronting. I have much to think about on this. Thanks for sharing it.

×

TRENDING: Caught in the Act: Reputation and Relationship >>